Gay Utah is the fourth pageant of each reign, and is held in January. This pageant is the second pageant where we allow contestants from the age of 18-20 to compete for the Gay Utah Youth titles, in conjunction with the adult titles. Winning titleholders will spend their year holding a minimum of two functions to raise money for the community.
Reigning Titleholders
| MR. GAY UTAH XXXVIII | MISS GAY UTAH XXXVIII | MS. GAY UTAH XXXVIII |
 |  |  |
| DEVIN AIRE | KIR ROYALE | KATELYNN JOHNSON |
| NUMBER | YEAR | Mr. Gay Utah | Miss Gay Utah | Ms. Gay Utah |
| I | 1983-1984 | Randy Snead | Tracey Ross | |
| II | 1984-1985 | Bill Arnold | Anita Baez | |
| III | 1985-1986 | Angel Ott | Natalie | |
| IV | 1986-1987 | Mike Manning | Platinum Giovanni | |
| V | 1987-1988 | Alan Palmer | Seville LaShae | |
| VI | 1988-1989 | Earl Kane | Ken Culligan (K.C.) | |
| VII | 1989-1990 | Scott Morgan | Bianca | |
| VIII | 1990-1991 | Alan Strange | Keisha | |
| IX | 1991-1992 | Alan Ofeldt | Electra | |
| X | 1992-1993 | Peter Christie | Tatiana | |
| XI | 1993-1994 | Mark Erickson | Veronika | |
| XII | 1994-1995 | Jeff Kosewski | Katrina | |
| XIII | 1995-1996 | Rio | Felicia | |
| XIV | 1996-1997 | Tim Budd | Mahogany | |
| XV | 1997-1998 | Charlie Ward | Selena Brunner | |
| XVI | 1998-1999 | Ducky | Syren Vaughn | |
| XVII | 1999-2000 | Dig | Kyra Prespentt | |
| XVIII | 2000-2001 | Horice Bilbo | Katie Harding | |
| XIX | 2001-2002 | Mark Thrash | Dominique | |
| XX | 2002-2003 | Danny Eggers | Tiffany Crystal | |
| XXI | 2003-2004 | Hunter Down | Charise Jamison | Beth Delavonte |
| XXII | 2004-2005 | Wee | Legacy Highway | Jewels |
| XXIII | 2005-2006 | Nikki Reeves | Shardonee | |
| XXIV | 2006-2007 | Mark James | Mya Chanel | Tricia LiQue |
| XXV | 2007-2008 | Jody Stamback | Emily Rose | Mandee |
| XXVI | 2008-2009 | Brian | Nova Starr | |
| XXVII | 2009-2010 | Kam Ellington | Coko Couture | Angela Dominguez |
| XXVIII | 2010-2011 | Rene Cordova | Lolita Steele | Courtney Marcus |
| XXIX | 2011-2012 | Nick Watts | Passion Starr | Kay Harvey |
| XXX | 2012-2013 | Alina Grey | ||
| XXXI | 2013-2014 | Eden DelMar-Giovanni | ||
| XXXII | 2014-2015 | Savannah VanCartier | ||
| XXXIII | 2015-2016 | Passion Giovanni | Haven Prespentt | |
| XXXIV | 2016-2017 | Christopher LaFleur | Princess Nika | |
| XXXV | 2017-2018 | London Skies | Delta Rae Dixon | |
| XXXVI | 2018-2019 | Gia Bianca Stephens | Victory Red | |
| XXXVII | 2019-2020 | The Whore of 94 | Phaedra Phoenix |